"I really liked the style and comfort of this shoe, but had to return them after buying online. Standing around it look great, but the problem with the happened whenever I tried to walk. I have narrow feet and ankles, so my foot would come almost completely out of the shoe whenever I walked. Finding boots and booties with narrow tops and ankle fit is a challenge for me, so I wasn't surprised when these shoes had the same issue. But, if you don't have this problem, then this would be a great style for you !"
"I was looking for either a loafer or an oxford style shoe for fall and mild winter days. While it's technically an oxford, this shoe is a happy medium of both for me. I tried them on with cuffed jeans, and have worn them with straight leg pants and ankle length pants for work. I ordered my normal size for flats, and I have narrow feet so they are a little loose width-wise, but I will find some sort of heel grip/sticky fit things to help with that. That also means I can get away with wearing a pair of socks and long pants for winter with them too - not always the most stylish, but function over fashion wins in Michigan winters."