"I tried the black, size 11 on in-store. My foot went in comfortably, although there was a slight pinch in the toe area. I figured with foot petals, the toe area would be bearable. I decided to hold off on the black, and went online & bought the red instead. The red shoe has a COMPLETELY different fit! I could barely get my foot into the shoe. In fact, I gave up trying. Unfortunately, these shoes will be going back to the store. Beautiful quality suede and jacquard though."