"I bought these a year ago, and they have been my go-to shoe ever since. The leather is good quality for the price, and responds well to cream polish. It's held up well even after being exposed to the insane amount of salt they use in the parking lots where I work. The leather interior is extremely comfortable - I wear dress shoes every day at work, and these I wear with jeans on my days off.
My only serious gripe is that the color on the back of the heels wore off, and I've had a really hard time finding a brown heel and edge polish to fix it. As others have noted, the leather soles are a bit slippery at the beginning, but these have broken in very well, and have held up against the crazy salt I have to deal with.
All in all I would recommend highly especially in a business casual environment. I would give it 4.5 stars if that were an option."