"I got this shoe in an 8 at the suggestion of some other reviews that indicated to go up half a size if you wanted to wear thicker socks with the boot and was truly disappointed when they arrived and fit more like there was an entire size difference. I ended up gifting them to my sister-in-law who usually wears an 8.5 and they fit her perfectly with some breathing room. I would've kept them and exchanged for my actual size (7.5) but they were out of stock :( I'd suggest buying them in your size despite what the other reviews say. It's really a beautiful and great quality shoe for the price."
"I received a pair in cognac for Christmas (they were on my wish list prior to) and I absolutely love them! They go perfect with skinny jeans and fit true to size. I wear a 7.5 but tried an 8 in-store since they were out and I was just swimming in them. They are a bit snug on the sides at the on-set but that's nothing a few wears can't take care of. The color is slightly darker in person and the toe doesn't point up as much as the picture depicts. All in all a great buy or gift!"