"I bought these black boots and have only worn them once, but so far they are comfortable and I have no complaints. I wore them with skinny jeans and there was still room in the calf even with jeans on. I haven't worn them with a skirt yet, but think maybe the calf might be too big. Just depends on your personal taste."
"Comfortable shoes and I had compliments on them the first time I wore them. I ended up putting in some heel pads to keep the heel from slipping on me, but I have a narrow heel, so not unusual. I'm between an 8 and 8 1/2, so I have to sometimes make shoes work."