"I bought these on a whim while at the store. I'm typically a 7.5 and the only size left was a 7. I purchased the black, and the brown buckle just really classes up the look. The 7 fits perfectly and is comfy enough for my thick wool socks. Calf size is great too, there is a buckle to tighten or loosen as needed. I haven't noticed the interior lining coming out, but I can see that it looks like it totally could. This is not a tall boot, more like mid-calf height. I've not experienced any ripping of the leather. Overall, great quality for the price."