"I gave this boot one star because I like the color. That's where the pro's end. Con's - this boot has the shape and fit of a rain boot. The ankle is very loose and when you walk it bunches and makes a crinkling noise. This boot is listed as synthetic leather and boy they couldn't be more right. This fake leather contributes to the issue of the rain boot fit the leather is very rigid. I have seen better faux leather on a $20 pair of boots. For $60 I expected A LOT more. I realize $60 isn't much for the boot/shoe world but this is not worth more than $20 from a super discount box store. I cannot get them out of my house and back to the store fast enough."