"These boots do have a narrow calf but so do I. I did order a half size up & they fit perfectly without thick socks on. These are a bit snug around my foot but I imagine with some wear will loosen slightly. Even if they didn't though, they're great. These boots look more grey than light brown in some lighting, which is more what I wanted anyway. These are real leather and smell amazing. I LOVE these boots! My new favorite!!"