"They run really big and loose in the ankle area, but I think with a sock on they will be fine. The adjustable back strap is super helpful with a wider calf (16" Calf FYI) . I am 5' - 6" and come up on me mid-calf. Wear a 8.5 and the 9 fit, with a sock on will be perfect. The foot is a little narrow, but again with a sock I think it will just hold the boot to my foot better. The insoles they give you are thin and come out every time you remove the boot. I would replace those. My boyfriend saw them and wanted a pair, a shame they don't offer in men's sizes. Haven't worn them in the rain yet so I cant tell you how they will hold up but with a 60 day return policy you cant go wrong. Seems to be built well and will wear well. For $50 I would give them a try!"