"Received these and wore them ONCE to church. Super cute and pretty comfy. Slightly narrow but works for my feet. I wear a size 8 and the size 8 fit perfect. When I got home from church, I noticed that the finish had already rubbed off on the toe of one of the boots and around the edges of the black sole on both boots. It's not like I was "rough" with these shoes. I was at church! Mostly sitting! So I'm super bummed. Hope they can exchange them. Not very practical."