"I'm normally a size 6.5. I bought these in black in size 7 since they run a little smaller, and the 7's fit well. I figured since the size 7's work (in black), I decided to order them in pewter (size 7 as well). I was disappointed when they arrived because they fit even smaller, so I would probably need a 7.5 in the pewter. I just wish the sizing was more consistent..."