"Now, this is a nice looking shoe. Well constructed, good price. Only thing that's missing is the "leather smell" (meaning for faux-patent leather it looks very real--and I do have some real patent leather to compare it too). Perfect for the days the raindrops might leave marks on suede, but boots are either not appropriate or over-kill. The detailing is reminiscent of menswear, but overall the shoe is acceptably feminine.
As far as comfort, I can see how they would be really, really comfy for someone with a wider foot. Let me explain. I am between a 7.5 and 8 and had to go with the 7.5 to get that foot hugging feel you want in a loafer (I bought these in store so I tried on both). Nothing that kills them for some shopping, but my toes start feeling a bit cramped if I end up walking all day in them. All in all, definitely a classy and well made shoe."