"Very cute shoe but had to return. I usually wear between a 9 and 91/2 depending on the brand. I tried on the 9 1/2 in the store and loved the look but it was too long. So I order a 9 only because none was available in store. The 9 was too long so I returned it in store and no 8 1/2 to try. Might try to get the 8 1/2 online..."