"I originally planned to only buy the brown, but they went on sale so I ordered both brown and black. Upon receiving them, I actually like the black better and will keep them. The brown is not exactly as it looks on the website; it is a lighter, duller, less warm brown. I am returning the brown. Neither is as small in the calf as I'd like, but since you can tighten the buckle on the calf, that helps. These are super comfortable. I love that they are actual leather instead of plastic."
"These boots are really cute, and the calf is just the right size for me. They run long in the foot, though, so they are going back. I wish they had a 5.5."