"First let me say that this shoe is absolutely GORG!!! I ordered this shoe in Cognac a week ago and received it this morning. I was so excited to wear these but when I opened the box I noticed little scuffs all over both shoes; this led me to believe that the shoes were supposed to have that "worn look," so no big deal right? WRONG! I looked at the soles and there was obvious wear on them. In addition to that, one of the shoes was two-toned (like an unprotected leather shoe that was exposed to water). It's with a heavy heart that I say that I am returning these shoes tomorrow at my local store for a full refund. I gave the "Nelly" two stars because of the design and feel of leather. Maybe I just ended up with the irregular pair of the lot, but I feel so defeated that I won't bother exchanging; INCREDIBLY DISAPPOINTED!"