"I ordered the Aetrex Heather Riding Boot in the brown and I love it!" The boots are extremely comfortable. The only reason I gave the boot a 4 was because the zipper broke. However, I loved the boots so much that I reordered them. I ordered a half size up and I'm glad I did. The brown is a rich chocolate and the stretchy part on the back of the boot was great for my thick calves. Way to go DSW for selling such a great product in a variety of sizes!"