"The boots fit, which was great because I have generally been between sizes even in this same brand. In this boot I ordered the larger of the sizes I'm between and it is a little roomy but not shaking around unwearably like the others. Something about the shape of the sole was more comfortable than other boots I've tried, and the lining is soft and warm. They're guaranteed leakproof for 6 months but I'm not sure what happens after that because the quality looks a bit subpar.
My big gripe is just that somehow in person they do not look as nice as the picture. Technically they are the same as the picture but in the picture I thought they looked cute and in person they look a little ugly to me. Trying to decide whether to just keep them anyway because they fit."