"I've been wearing these for a week, and I found them to be incredibly comfy. I did have to buy one half-size up, because they just LOOK small, like womens' shoes. Also, the size-up fits more comfortably. I don't lace the top eyelet because I like them to slip-on. Yesterday I wore them through several deep puddles in the park, and though I did treat them with waterproofing spray, my feet stayed dry and they did not leak.
Minor issue - some minor pain above heel from wearing these shoes - but I can't be certain it's the shoe. There is a little plastic "nub" under the padding that kinda pokes through a little. It's not bothering me enough to stop wearing them."