"I love Amalfi shoes and have worn several pairs. I loved the look of this sandal and it's beautifully made in a gorgeous color. Having said that, this shoe is incredibly narrow. The 9.5 medium width is my normal size, but I could not get even my toes into this sandal. When I compare the sole width to my other shoes (also 9.5 med. width), these were a full 3/4" narrower. I was really disappointed to have to return them. On the plus side, DSW was very prompt in sending out the shoe, and equally accommodating in my return."