"I only had one problem with the boot but is was a deal breaker. They ran very long. They were a good half inch longer than my other boots. I had a lot of empty space at the toe. I purchased an 11.5. I have worn a 12 and been happy before so I was surprised when theses seemed longer still. The width seemed about right so based on this experience I believe you would have to go a full size down and have a very thin foot. It is always possible I got an odd pair though. DSW just did not have another pair to try."