"I have an absurdly wide calf (15.5" calf, 5'10"- 145lbs) and was excited to see this boot. The calf is definitely wide with room to spare. The top gaps a bit, but would be able to wear the cute, thick cable sock with these. Leather is distressed and easily marked but adds to the character. The foot itself was comfortable and didn't need much break in time. Good leather boot for the price."